Wednesday, May 11, 2022

Freedom Of Expression

 

My world has always been coloured by and in a world dominated by the political system of Apartheid- a world in which Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela was ever present in terms of his physical presence being incarcerated a mere few kilometres from where I lived and in fact during my life I had cause to visit the island prison no fewer than 15 times… This essay loosely tracks this strange world in which I and the “father of my nation” lived almost side by side yet truly, worlds apart. 

In 1945 my father shipped back to South Africa . He was not the same man that had left the shores of Cape Town some 3 years earlier. Part of him remained in Tobruk, on the streets of Italy along with two children he had seen, huddled together and frozen to death on a park bench. Another part was left in the mud under the half-track that had almost taken his life one August afternoon and which was to take his life at the age of 52, some 24 years later. And the tears that often welled up when he sat in silence, hunched over his reel to reel tape recorder trying to make sense of his life some year later, were those tears reserved for his partner whose head had disappeared from a dum- dum bullet that had shattered the windscreen of the military vehicle they were travelling in. I was to be born some 7 years after he stood at the dock in Cape Town along with others of the Sappers that had returned.

And I was to enjoy some of the “freedom of expression” he had fought for, even though his own “freedom of expression” now hid behind clouded eyes.

In 1948, 3 years after those who had fought for freedom in the world, had returned, the Nationalist Party in South Africa came to power. Despite having fought alongside their white compatriots, the black and coloured soldiers would now be denied the right to vote and their oppression under the new regime would grow apace in the ensuing years.

4 Years later, in 1952 in a nursing home in Kenilworth Cape Town, I would be born, the only son to a man who had sacrificed much and been given nothing back by a country which would now become  a world pariah.

In 1964 after the Rivonia treason Trial Nelson Rohlihala Mandela was sentenced to life imprisonment on Robben Island. I was then in Standard Four, a 12 year old oblivious to the political machinations and only slightly aware of the fact that I attended a whites only school, travelled in whites only sections of buses and trains. That the man who worked in the garden was coloured and the woman who came to the house once a week to help my mother clean was also coloured meant nothing at all! This was how things were supposed to be in my well protected, well sanitized world. I also had no idea that in fact I was growing up in the “poorer” suburbs and that my parents at that stage were deciding how they would be able to afford sending me to a “wealthier” suburban school some distance from where we stayed. But send me they did!

In 1966, the cotton -wool cocoon world that I lived in suddenly began to dissipate like proverbial candy floss. Each day I cycled some 7 kilometres in one direction  to attend a school on the slopes of Table Mountain, just below the University of Cape Town and another 3 kilometres from where a famous surgeon would perform the world’s first heart transplant taking the heart of a young girl, Denise Darvall, the accident which had caused her premature passing taking place in the road I travelled each day. The headlines became part of my history, and Louis Washkansky the recipient, was closely followed in the newspapers. Somehow the world had been forced to notice another side of the “pariah”.  For me though the “Freedom of Expression” I had seemingly enjoyed was now becoming filled with questions… the teachers at my school, Westerford High, many of whom were anti -apartheid activists, were leaving questions in my mind, and a young girl who sat two rows in front of me, Ruth Carneson would soon leave due to the actions being taken on her anti -apartheid parents by the authorities. I was slowly awakening.

Freedom of Expression? Was that what I was enjoying whilst a few kilometres away from where I would enjoy a day at the beach, Nelson Mandela and his compatriots chipped rocks in the midday Robben Island sun.

Freedom of Expression? Was this what I was enjoying when I was visited by the police shortly after I had begun visiting a coloured friend in the then District Six area?

Freedom of Expression? Was this what I enjoyed when I was ostracized by family and friends when I had had the temerity to fall in love with a coloured girl, a relationship which was of course doomed from the start due to our freedom of expression. I was white- she was not! The irony only became supremely evident when many, many years later, my younger sister in tracing the family tree, discovered a hitherto undiscovered coloured branch.

1969 and whilst still at school and about to write my final examinations, my father passed away. The times I had sat at his feet and listed to him as he shared some secrets of life would now no longer continue. He had started an ardent Nationalist Party supporter- it was fairly obvious but also paradoxical he would be a Nationalist, after all, he had sacrificed much as he took up arms against the Nazi threat. The years though mellowed the truck driver who had wanted to study and become a gynaecologist but never had the funds to pursue his dream… a dream he would pass on to his son, although the gynae part was not something his son would aspire to. The truck driver too, would begin to question the Nationalist party propaganda machine and the allegiance would change to the PFP or Progressive Federal Party.

The South African apartheid system was though at the height of its power and in 1971, scores of young men, who had recently completed their formal school, were conscripted to fight in a war most of us had no idea why. The idea of a Communist threat, lurking on an Angolan border was to erase much of our freedom of expression as it had done to our father’s some 30 years earlier. Under the guise of protecting our freedom, my friends lost theirs- sometimes in a hail of bullets. I was fortunate and lived.

1976 the anti -apartheid movement had begun to foment and South Africa was not only a world pariah but was slowly being isolated by sanctions in many forms- perhaps one of the most effective sanctions occurred when the national sporting teams of Rugby and Cricket were banned from participating against other countries. South Africa, although relatively small in numbers, is an extremely proud sporting nation and to be isolated by the world (in the UK Peter Hain was a major force for change in this sense, advocating the isolation of South Africa). For me, along with many of my sporting colleagues this was a personal blow as I had been fortunate to be selected for Provincial Cricket, Soccer and Hockey teams and suddenly the prospect of a career in sport was taken away from me… was this the ”freedom of Expression” I would reflect on in later years? I had already served my country in one tour of duty as a soldier…I had already lost a love due to the political dispensation, now I faced the prospect of losing the opportunity of representing my country in the  international sporting arena.

As an educationalist the world of 1976 became very real as the young people of my country rebelled against having to learn a language (Afrikaans) deemed to be the language of the oppressor. For me, “freedom of Expression” had disappeared and I packed up my children (both toddlers)… my wife had left me for another, and I travelled to Namibia where I hope to avoid the plague that I found myself in in my own country. On reflection I was merely in a sense, doing a “Lady Macbeth” and trying to wash the blood off my own hands.

Nelson Mandela was still on the island! Freedom of Expression belonged only to the White minority! It would be another 14 years before he would be able to shake the Robben Island dust off his feet.

In the interim I was able to have a modicum of freedom and was (eventually) able to represent Namibia in Cricket, and provincially in both Hockey and Soccer. It was a small realization of what I could have achieved in my own country had we not been isolated.

This week the world has celebrated (celebrated?) the Freedom of the Press/Freedom of Expression. The USA is arguably one of the few countries able to celebrate “Freedom of Expression”/Freedom of the Press, whereas most countries will have some restrictive measures in place- Post 1994 in South Africa our country has been somewhat “free-er” but regrettably the new government is slowly becoming more and more austere in its approach to freedom of expression and one is very careful as to what one says in public spaces and especially if one is critical of people in government.

Allow me though to return to the idea that the world seems to have that Nelson Mandela was a/the primary causal factor in the ultimate removal of the Apartheid system and the eventual democratic elections of 1994. It is not my aim to downplay his role nor the advocate of peace that he was but perhaps at this juncture it may be worthwhile to reflect briefly on the idea of freedom of expression as it was from the outset in terms of the growth and development of the country called South Africa.

As was similar in many colonial countries from the 15th and 16th Centuries South Africa was “discovered” by Portuguese in their quest to discover a spice route per se. Cape Town on the  southern  tip of Africa became a so called refreshment station for ships (sailors) where they could stop and take on drums of water and various other items such as vegetables grown at the Dutch East India Companies gardens on the slopes of Table Mountain. History has shown that the then settlers m oved into the interior of the country, clashed with the Xhosa/Zulu tribes initially and so began the colonial expansion and settlement of the country by the then Dutch/English/French and various other white colonialists who obviously in their settlement (having superior weapons) dispossessed the inhabitants of their land and who then became labourers on what essentially had been their land originally. Freedom as they knew it in the early years of the development of South Africa belonged primarily to the settlers. I mention this as the idea/concept of Freedom of Expression existed before the arrival of White Settlers but in a sense of a relationship between what was then warring Black tribes. I will allow the reader to gain their own sense of how this freedom existed as it does not take much of a leap to understand how the hierarchy within the tribes, run by a King and his supervisors (a Sangoma- witchdoctor being of paramount importance) and how limited the freedom would have been for the non -royalty tribe members.

Having stated the aforesaid I purposed this to allow the reader a better understanding that South Africa has had many men and women perhaps with as great a stature as Nelson Mandela who litter the history of the country with their efforts to be free and removed from what was considered the yoke of colonialism. Recently South Africa renamed an Eastern Cape airport after one such person namely David Stuurman, who has the debatable honour of being possibly the only Robben Island prisoner to have escaped from the island- the first time being in 1809, and in fact escaped no fewer than 3 times. David Stuurman is also arguably one of the first to rebel against the colonialists who had dispossessed him and his people of their land.

In conclusion:

It is not within the context of this paper to examine the heroes who fought against racial domination which eventually became the cornerstone of South African politics under the guise of Apartheid, but rather to give a sense that many sacrificed their lives over hundreds of years prior to the dismantling of Apartheid under the leadership of Nelson Mandela and hence the giving of credence to Freedom of Expression in South Africa which we now enjoy.

Perhaps though even more than the greatness of the man in enabling South Africa to move from and oppressive State peacefully, would be some of the things he left behind to carry the country ever onwards and upwards. One of these would be his 10 rules for success:

1.      Demand Respect

2.      Prove them wrong

3.      Use your time wisely

4.      Don’t worry about labels

5.      Be humble

6.      Have heroes

7.      Take a stand

8.      Manage your emotions

9.      Be willing to die for your cause

10.   Speak with conviction

If ever a person stood for the rights of humanity and the right to freedom of expression, Nelson Rolihlala Mandela (Madiba) epitomized that.

No comments: